Skip to content

The Baldwin Group to go private. Read a message from our CEO here.

Collectibles

If You Like It, Put a Policy On It

The Baldwin Group
|
Updated: April 29, 2026
|
3 minute read

You finally got it. Maybe it was a painting from an artist you’ve admired for years, sports memorabilia from your favorite athlete, or a family heirloom that you want to pass onto the next generation. After dedicating time and energy toward acquiring art or collectibles, protecting it should be top of mind. While the first thing you may think about doing is putting it behind a lock and key in a temperature-controlled room, insurance should also be a part of your thought process. If you own art or collectibles worth more than a few thousand dollars, then it’s worth insuring them.

Though a typical homeowners insurance policy can provide some coverage, it’s usually very little – anywhere from about $2,000 to $5,000 total for each class of valuables. This is why we recommend purchasing additional coverage for any fine art or collectible items you own. Consider insuring valuable items on a separate valuables or collections policy. Depending on the circumstances, you might also be able to extend the coverage of your homeowners policy by purchasing a rider to cover fine art and collectibles.

Examples of items that might require additional coverage:

  • Fine art
  • Furs
  • Rugs
  • Collectibles (figurines, stamps, glassware, coins)
  • Silverware
  • One-of-a-kind furniture
  • Heirlooms
  • China
  • Instruments
  • Jewelry
  • Crystal
  • Wine

If you’re considering insuring high-value items like those listed, there are specific steps you’ll need to take.

The first step you’ll need to take is putting together provenance. Provenance is all the necessary documentation that proves the valuable item is yours and what it’s currently worth. These documents include the following:

  • Proof of ownership
  • Bill of sale
  • Replacement estimate
  • Most recent appraisal

Be sure you store all these documents in an accessible and organized manner. We suggest also taking photos of all valuables and turning copies of the documents over to a trusted third party in the event that a catastrophic event at your home ends in the loss of those important documents.

You’ll need to get an appraisal of an item to be able to determine the value of what you’re insuring. This will help you determine the amount and type of coverage you should get. Regularly getting appraisals for fine art and collectibles also helps you plan your estate, file your taxes, and know the overall value of your collection. Find a reputable appraiser in your area that specializes in the item(s) you want to insure.

Different insurers will have varying stances on how recent valuations must be. When you schedule an appraisal, be sure to specify that it’s for insurance purposes. How often you should get an appraisal depends on the age and medium of the piece. Regularly submitting up-to-date appraisals to your carrier will ensure that you have enough coverage in the event of a loss and are less likely to be underinsured. Our private client team can help you determine when you should schedule an appraisal for any fine art or collectible items you own.

It’s important to protect your collection with a policy that is designed for the intricacies of the unique items you own. When picking coverage, consider the following:

  • Will the carrier cover both lost and stolen items?
  • Does the policy allow for extension of coverage beyond an item’s scheduled value (appreciation)?
  • Can the policy extend coverage for newly acquired items?
  • If an item sustains damage while in transit, will it be covered?
  • Depending on what you need, will your policy pay to repair and/or replace an item?
  • Should a piece get damaged and its value is diminished due to a covered loss, will the carrier settle the loss for diminution of value?
  • If you lose part of a set or pair, will your insurance allow you to replace all items with a matching set?

There are many variables to consider when you’re choosing insurance for fine art and collectibles. Our private client team has experience working in this space and can help you manage and select the right coverage for the assets you’ve worked hard to obtain and protect.

Use our advisors’ knowledge to guide you toward the coverage you need.

Related Insights

Stay one step ahead

Discover expert insights to help you understand industry trends and emerging risks, so you can act proactively to better protect your business.

Personal Cyber
Cyber risk doesn't stay in its lane
In a digitally connected household, a smart lock, a home network, or a connected camera often runs on the same...
Wealth Management
Align insurance with generational wealth transfer
With an estimated $84 trillion set to transfer between generations in the coming decades, successful families have a unique opportunity...
High Value Homes
What a stronger El Niño season means for your flood risk
The Baldwin Group is closely tracking this season's flood outlook for clients across the country, with a particular focus on...
Home and Property
Standard coverage vs. add-ons: A home buyer's guide
Standard homeowners insurance typically covers your home's structure, belongings, liability, and temporary living expenses after a covered loss, but it...
Luxury Marine
Yacht insurance explained: coverage types, costs and what owners need to know
Owning a yacht or mega yacht is one of life's great rewards—and one of its more complex responsibilities. Whether you're...